Close

Complete Captcha

• 10 years - 181 posts
• Thread: 42 Goods vs 22 No Goods

1. Kirk
   Rep: 1558

   Hi all,

   The beta of journal submission wiki is now up at
   http://www.econjobrumors.com/journals.php

   Would be great if you could submit some of your recent journal experiences to the wiki to get it going.

   It is currently a work in progress and feedback will be useful along the way. Please report feedback/suggestions here. A key decision will be whether to limit submissions to 'edu verified accounts' in the future.

   I will integrate it into the frontpage as well as the Research/Journals subforum page.

   If this takes off I will build more advanced features into it, such as a summary table for all journals, rather than on a by submission basis.

   How to use: Click Add row at the bottom of the page to add your journal submission experience

   Best
   K-dog

   10 years ago # QUOTE 59 Good 15 No Giod !

2. Economist
   75ad
   

   First!

   10 years ago # QUOTE 2 Good 16 No Giod !

3. Economist
   7325
   

   First!

   10 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 19 No Giod !

4. Economist
   7325
   

   ^ fvck

   10 years ago # QUOTE 6 Good 10 No Giod !

5. Economist
   4887
   

   Seems like N/A or something similar be an option for all dropdowns after the initial decision, if the paper got a first-round reject.

   The "result" dropdown should distinguish between desk rejects and refereed rejects (to distinguish between, say, lengthy desk rejects and very quick referee responses, which say very different things about the journal since, since as is, a desk reject would presumably just be reported by a reject after zero or one month length).

   10 years ago # QUOTE 1 Good 0 No Giod !

6. Kirk
   Rep: 1558

   ^Yes, thanks

   10 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 15 No Giod !

7. Economist
   73f4
   

   I think it would be more user friendly if zero were an option for response months and no. of referee reports.

   10 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod !

8. Kirk
   Rep: 1558

   ^Added

   10 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 15 No Giod !

9. Economist
   7325
   

   When did your nickname become K-dog? You can't just give yourself nicknames kirk.

   10 years ago # QUOTE 3 Good 6 No Giod !

10. Economist
    2206
    

    Shut up!

    Best,
    K-F**k

    When did your nickname become K-dog? You can't just give yourself nicknames kirk.

    10 years ago # QUOTE 2 Good 0 No Giod !

11. Economist
    9ce8
    

    Kirk:

    Thanks for adding this. But how are we supposed to add JME when he max response time is only 12 months.

    10 years ago # QUOTE 17 Good 0 No Giod !

12. Kirk
    Rep: 1558

    ^Updated and amended your submission

    10 years ago # QUOTE 1 Good 15 No Giod !

13. Economist
    e465
    

    I don't think that this is the correct way to report the durations. Maybe we should have a separate column for time to decision and another one for time to first response.

    10 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod !

14. Economist
    e34f
    

    Hopefully, the journal table would grow fast. Soon, we would need a summary table grouped by (journal, result, year submitted). But this feature can wait until the initial bugs are taken care of.

    Great tool!

    10 years ago # QUOTE 4 Good 0 No Giod !

15. Economist
    1159
    

    Is "Response" refering to first response? i.e., R&R request?

    10 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod !

16. Economist
    ce43
    

    1) It is very likely that some posts will have errors. I just submitted the correct information for wrong journal. Since we don't want to leave anonymity you can allow everyone to modify each post like Wikipedia
    2) Many times we only know (especially for old submissions) the time between first submission and date of final disposition set NOT the first response time. Maybe these should be in separate columns.

    10 years ago # QUOTE 1 Good 0 No Giod !

17. Economist
    b2e4
    

    A few journals to add:
    Journal of Finance (instead of "The Journal of Finance")
    Journal of Financial Econometrics
    Management Science
    Quantitative Finance
    Review of Finance
    Review of Financial Studies
    American Economic Journal: Applied Economics
    American Economic Journal: Economic Policy
    American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics
    American Economic Journal: Microeconomics

    Thanks; this is a great contribution to the community - again!

    10 years ago # QUOTE 4 Good 0 No Giod !

18. Kirk
    Rep: 1558

    ^thanks 3c02

    10 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 15 No Giod !

19. Economist
    e34f
    

    Round # would be useful as well (was it accepted/rejected after 1 round or gazillion?)

    10 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 1 No Giod !

20. Economist
    e34f
    

    Second Journal of Finance (instead of "The Journal of Finance")

    10 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod !

Reply »